| Mirror Image: Can outsourcing be stopped? |  |
| Opinion | |||
| Written by Reynaldo C. Lugtu Jr. | |||
| Tuesday, 18 November 2008 23:49 | |||
|
Now that President-elect Barack Obama will be inaugurated on January 20, 2009, many are holding their breath, especially the business-process outsourcing companies in India, the Philippines and others, as to how he can turn around the outsourcing of jobs from the United States. In debates and on the road, Obama repeatedly said that if elected, he would discourage companies from "shipping jobs overseas" by taking away tax breaks, or by giving benefit to those corporations that keep jobs domestically. "We can keep giving tax breaks to companies that ship jobs overseas, or we can give tax benefits to companies that invest right here in New Hampshire," Senator Obama said at a joint appearance with Sen. Hillary Clinton in Unity, New Hampshire. According to CIO magazine, economists and legal advisers contacted about those comments said they are unaware of any specific tax breaks aimed at offshoring or outsourcing tech jobs. Instead, they said, Obama may be targeting broader tax-deferment strategies, such as the ability of multinational firms to avoid taxes on profits by moving money overseas. But can corporate tax policy alone really do much in stopping the offshoring of US jobs? Some analysts don't believe so. "Any plans for a Tax Code change are like trying to plug a hole in a leaky dam with your finger—to believe the US government Tax Code promotes outsourcing is a major misconception of the fiery debate around outsourcing offshore," according to Joe Greco, director of California State University-Fullerton's Center for the Study of Emerging Markets. Also, according to a Computerworld report, Nielsen Co., the media company known for audience measurement, has given up tens of thousands of dollars in local tax breaks this year after signing up with an outsourcing provider based in India. Back in 2004, John Kerry was, likewise, criticized for using the same tax-policy argument against offshoring. Factcheck.org, a political-analyst group, pointed out that taxes "are a very small part" of companies' decisions to move jobs offshore. Those at a 2005 Brookings Institution summit on trade also said taxes had little to do with outsourcing. In addition, Joel Slemrod, a tax expert at the University of Michigan's business school, said that, "For those who see [offshoring] as a problem, this is not a solution." And so US companies continue to outsource. One glaring reason is the huge cost differential between the United States and offshore providers. A programmer can be hired in China for $12 an hour while the same goes for $56 in the United States. Depending on the skill and location of the offshore vendor, the international wage ratio can reach 100:1 as corporations outsource to where they can reduce costs and maximize profits. Experts predict that the significant cost differential between the United States and other countries will continue for 30 years. Although cost reduction is the major reason US companies do offshoring, there are a number of others why firms do it. According to a 2004 Outsourcing World Summit report, of the Western firms that do offshoring, 9 percent want to gain access to skills and 3 percent require innovation from the outsourcing vendor, and the number is growing. And why not? China and India graduate a combined half a million engineers and scientists a year, versus 60,000 in the United States; India and the Philippines are already recognized globally as the hotbed of information-technology innovation and creativity in the areas of programming, animation and design. Many of the outsourcing professionals and executives in India and the Philippines are not bothered by the pronouncements of Obama during the campaign. Outsourcing will continue to flourish in the coming years as corporations find ways to stay competitive. As India's Finance Minister P. Chidambaram commented, "Once Obama is in office, he will realize that it is an interconnected world, and countries have to work together."
"Mirror Image" is a rotating column featuring writers from the DLSU Professional Schools Inc. Reynaldo C. Lugtu Jr. teaches management and marketing courses in the MBA program of De La Salle Uiniversity Graduate School of Business. He may be e-mailed at rlugtu2002@yahoo.com or visit his blog at http://rlugtu.blogspot.com.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment